No, if it is paid under an accountable plan at or below the IRS standard mileage rate. Yes, on every dollar, if it is not. There is no partial credit for good intentions here. An employer either meets three specific tests in the regulations or the payment lands in box 1 of your W-2 as ordinary wages, subject to income tax withholding, Social Security and Medicare.
Sources: Treas. Reg. 26 CFR 1.62-2 (reimbursements and other expense allowance arrangements); IRS Publication 463; IRS Internal Revenue Bulletin 2026-29 (2026 standard mileage rates).
The three tests an accountable plan has to pass
Treas. Reg. 1.62-2 sets out the whole framework, and all three requirements apply at once:
- Business connection. The payment has to cover a deductible business expense you incurred while working for the employer. Reimbursing personal driving fails immediately.
- Substantiation within a reasonable time. You give the employer the date, the destination, the business purpose and the mileage. The regulation offers a safe harbor of 60 days after the expense to substantiate.
- Return of any excess within a reasonable time. If you were advanced more than your documented miles support, the difference goes back. The safe harbor there is 120 days.
Fail any one and the arrangement is a non-accountable plan for that payment. The consequence is not that the excess becomes taxable. The whole amount becomes taxable.
Paying above the IRS rate splits the payment
An employer may reimburse at any rate it likes. The tax treatment splits at the IRS figure. For 2026 that figure changed mid-year:
- 72.5 cents per mile for business miles driven 1 January to 30 June 2026
- 76 cents per mile for business miles driven 1 July to 31 December 2026
Reimburse 1,000 September miles at 85 cents and $760 is tax-free while $90 is wages. The employer reports the excess on the W-2 and withholds on it. The portion at or under the rate stays off the W-2 entirely and is not reported as income.
Under-reimbursing does not create a deduction for employees
This is the part people get wrong most often. If the reimbursement is below the IRS rate, a W-2 employee cannot deduct the shortfall. Unreimbursed employee business expenses were suspended for 2018 through 2025 by the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act, and the OBBBA made that suspension permanent. The federal answer for most employees is now simply no. We walk through the narrow exceptions in deducting mileage after reimbursement.
If you are an independent contractor, the rules are different
A client paying you for mileage is not running an accountable plan for you, because you are not their employee. That money is business income. It usually shows up inside the total on your 1099-NEC and you report it on Schedule C.
The offset is that you then deduct the actual miles at the standard rate on line 9. If the client paid you 60 cents and the rate is 76 cents, you report the 60 and deduct the 76. The 16-cent gap is real deductible value, which is the opposite of the employee outcome above.
Does a flat monthly car allowance count as reimbursement?
Almost never. A fixed monthly amount paid regardless of miles driven has no business connection to a specific documented expense, so it fails test one and is fully taxable. See is a car allowance taxable for what it takes to convert one into a compliant arrangement.
What records does the employee actually have to hand over?
The same four elements the IRS wants behind any mileage deduction: date, destination, business purpose and miles. A monthly total with no trip detail is not substantiation, and an employer relying on one is running a non-accountable plan whether it realises it or not. Our log requirements guide covers the standard.
Is the reimbursement subject to Social Security and Medicare tax?
Only the taxable portion. Amounts paid under an accountable plan at or below the rate are excluded from wages for income tax withholding, Social Security, Medicare and federal unemployment tax alike. Excess or unsubstantiated amounts are wages for all of them.
An accountable plan is only as good as the trip records feeding it. TruMile captures date, destination, purpose and mileage automatically, so substantiation is a monthly export instead of a monthly argument. Try TruMile →
Get the next rate change in your inbox
Mileage rates and tax deadlines, when they change. A few emails a year.
Track every business mile.
40 auto trips a month, free forever. Switch from any tracker with a one-tap CSV import.
Download free on the App Store